The Biggest Myth of All? That All Annuities Are the Same.
Annuities generate strong opinions. Some people view them as valuable retirement tools. Others dismiss them as expensive, complicated or restrictive.
Part of the confusion comes from treating every annuity as though it were the same product. It isn't.
Fixed annuities, fixed indexed annuities, registered index-linked annuities (RILAs) and variable annuities can have very different purposes, risks, costs and features.
That means some common criticisms of annuities may be true for a particular product or contract — but misleading when applied to every annuity. Here are five of the biggest misconceptions.
Myth 01
“All Annuities Are Basically the Same.”
Reality
Different annuities can have very different purposes, risks and features.
“Annuity” describes a broad category of insurance contracts — not one single product. Four major types consumers may encounter include:
Fixed Annuity
Provides a stated or guaranteed minimum rate of interest according to the contract and is generally designed around predictability and contractual guarantees.
Fixed Indexed Annuity
Interest-crediting potential is linked in part to the performance of a market index, subject to contract terms. Negative index performance generally does not create a negative index-linked interest credit.
RILA
A registered index-linked annuity provides index-linked return potential while exposing the consumer to a defined degree of market loss based on the contract.
Variable Annuity
Contract value can rise or fall based on the performance of the investment options selected.
Why It Matters
Saying “I don’t like annuities” can be a little like saying “I don’t like investments.”
The better question is: Which type? For what purpose? And under what circumstances?
Myth 02
“Once You Buy an Annuity, Your Money Is Completely Locked Up.”
Reality
Many annuities allow withdrawals — but access and potential consequences depend on the contract.
Annuities are generally designed as long-term financial products, and many contracts have surrender periods. But long-term does not necessarily mean you have no access to your money. Depending on the contract:
- A certain amount may be available each year without a surrender charge.
- Withdrawals above permitted amounts may trigger surrender charges.
- Withdrawals may reduce contract benefits.
- Taxes or other consequences may apply.
- Certain contracts may provide additional withdrawal provisions or waivers under qualifying circumstances.
Why It Matters
Liquidity should be evaluated before buying an annuity — not discovered when you need the money.
Ask: How much can I access, when can I access it, and what happens if I need more?
Myth 03
“All Annuities Have High Fees.”
Reality
Fee structures can vary dramatically by annuity type and contract.
Some fixed and fixed indexed annuities may have no explicit ongoing annual contract fee, although optional riders or features may carry charges and contract economics can affect credited interest.
Variable annuities can have more explicit costs, potentially including mortality and expense charges, administrative fees, underlying investment expenses and optional benefit charges.
The important point isn’t that annuities have fees or don’t have fees. It’s understanding how your particular contract works and what you’re paying for.
Explicit Costs
Charges deducted directly from your contract value.
Contract Economics
Terms such as caps, participation rates or spreads that can affect credited interest or upside.
Optional Features
Riders or benefits that may carry additional charges.
Why It Matters
Before buying an annuity, ask what costs are deducted directly from your contract, whether there are optional features that cost extra, and whether contract provisions limit potential interest or growth.
Why Are There So Many Conflicting Opinions About Annuities?
Because “annuity” describes a category — not a single product.
- Different Type
- Different Contract
- Different Features
- Different Costs
- Different Purpose
The better question isn’t “Are annuities good or bad?” It’s: “Does this particular annuity solve a problem I actually have — and are the trade-offs worth it?”
Myth 04
“If I Die, the Insurance Company Just Keeps My Money.”
Reality
What happens at death depends on the contract and the payout option selected.
Many annuities provide death-benefit provisions for named beneficiaries during the accumulation phase. Once income begins or a contract is annuitized, what happens at death can depend on the income option selected.
Depending on the contract and payout structure, benefits may:
- Continue for a surviving spouse.
- Continue for a guaranteed period.
- Provide remaining benefits to beneficiaries.
- Or potentially stop at death.
Why It Matters
Don’t assume. Understand the answer before you sign.
Ask: “What happens to this contract if I die tomorrow? What about after income begins?”
Myth 05
“An Annuity Is Only for Someone Who Needs Lifetime Income.”
Reality
Lifetime income is one important use of annuities — but it isn’t the only one.
Depending on the type and structure, annuities may be used to address different retirement objectives, including:
- Guaranteed lifetime income.
- Principal protection.
- Tax-deferred accumulation.
- Reducing exposure to market losses.
- Creating a protected portion of retirement assets.
- Death-benefit features.
- Certain optional living benefits.
Guaranteed Income
One retiree may own an annuity primarily to create predictable income they cannot outlive.
Growth & Protection
Another may own one primarily to pursue growth potential while limiting exposure to market losses.
Why It Matters
Two retirees could own annuities for completely different reasons. Neither objective automatically makes a particular annuity appropriate — the annuity still needs to fit the individual’s goals, financial situation, liquidity needs, timeline and risk tolerance.
Start with the retirement problem you’re trying to solve — not the product.
Don’t Ask “Is This a Good Annuity?” Yet
Ask These Questions First
- What type of annuity is it?
- What retirement problem is it intended to solve?
- What guarantees does it provide?
- What isn’t guaranteed?
- How can I access my money?
- What surrender charges apply?
- What costs should I understand?
- What happens when I die?
- What insurance company backs the guarantees?
- What am I giving up in exchange for the benefits I’m receiving?
The Bottom Line: Annuities Aren’t All Good — or All Bad
Annuities are financial contracts designed to accomplish different objectives. Some emphasize protection. Some emphasize income. Some provide market-linked growth potential. Some expose consumers to market losses. Costs, liquidity provisions, guarantees and benefits can also vary substantially.
That’s why broad statements such as “annuities are bad,” “annuities are expensive,” or “annuities lock up all your money” aren’t particularly useful without knowing which annuity and contract we’re talking about.
Sources
- 1.Annuities — Investor Publications — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (Investor.gov)
- 2.Updated Investor Bulletin: Indexed Annuities — U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
- 3.Annuities — Consumer Information — National Association of Insurance Commissioners
- 4.Buyer's Guide for Deferred Annuities — National Association of Insurance Commissioners
Go deeper in the Knowledge Hub
Educational guides that expand on the topics covered in this article.
Wondering Which Type of Annuity May Fit Your Retirement Goals?
The Annuity Finder can help you better understand your options based on your retirement priorities, timeline and goals.
Take the Free Annuity Finder Quiz
